Theo's Italian
Our verdict
Theo's Italian is listed as permanently closed following the June 22, 2026 status audit.

The menu
What to order
- Roman Style Pinsa
- Four-cheese ravioli
Theo's Italian is listed as permanently closed.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Theo's Italian located?
Theo's Italian is located at 2498 Perry Crossing Way Suite 105, Plainfield, IN 46168.
Is Theo's Italian a good option for a sit-down family dinner in the Plainfield area?
Theo's Italian sits inside a commercial suite at Perry Crossing in Plainfield, IN, a retail corridor that draws a broad suburban demographic and is associated with accessible, family-oriented dining. Italian-American restaurants in this format typically offer table service suited to group dining. Reservations are recommended.
What's a useful thing to order at Theo's Italian?
Theo's Italian serves Italian Pizza and Pasta. Italian-American kitchens in this suburban corridor typically anchor their menus around house pasta and red-sauce classics, making those categories a reliable starting point. Asking staff for that day's specials is one direct way to get an accurate picture.
How far ahead should I plan for Theo's Italian?
Reservations are recommended. Independent Italian restaurants in suburban commercial developments like Perry Crossing, Suite 105 tend to see heavier demand on Friday and Saturday evenings. Calling ahead or checking for an online reservation option on arrival is advisable for those time slots.
What do critics highlight about Theo's Italian?
Theo's Italian has no documented awards or ratings in the record. The restaurant operates in Plainfield, Indiana's western Indianapolis dining corridor, a market that has historically received less press coverage than the urban core. Verified editorial recognition, if it exists, would most likely appear in Indianapolis-area food publications.
Do they accommodate allergies at Theo's Italian?
Theo's Italian has a smart_casual dress code. One reliable approach is to contact the restaurant at its Plainfield address, 2498 Perry Crossing Way Suite 105, before visiting. Italian-American kitchens commonly work with gluten and dairy-heavy preparations, so flagging dietary requirements in advance gives the kitchen a stronger chance to adjust.
Price Lens
Comparable venues nearby, for context on price, style, and recognition.
| Venue | Cuisine | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Theo's ItalianThis venue (the venue you are viewing) | Italian Pizza and Pasta | Not listed | Not listed |
| Akira Japanese Steakhouse | Japanese Hibachi Steakhouse | $20–30 | Plainfield, Japanese Hibachi Steakhouse |
| Tlahcos | Upscale Authentic Mexican | $20–30 | Downtown Plainfield, Upscale Authentic Mexican |
| Stone Creek - Plainfield | Contemporary American Steakhouse | $30–50 | Perry Crossing, Plainfield, Contemporary American Steakhouse |
| Charbonos | Italian Steakhouse with Wood-Fired Pizzas | $20–30 | Avon, Italian Steakhouse with Wood-Fired Pizzas |
| Portofino | Italian-inspired Fine Dining | $50–100 | Geist, Italian-inspired Fine Dining |
Continue exploring
More in Plainfield
Restaurants in Plainfield
All restaurants in Plainfield →Details
- Cozy
- Elegant
- Family
- Date Night
- Casual Hangout
- Private Dining
- Local Sourcing
- A La Carte
Upscale casual atmosphere with elegant vibes, moderate noise, and a welcoming, comforting environment suitable for families and date nights.













