The Up & Up

Beneath Greenwich Village's storied streets, The Up & Up New York City transforms a century-old underground space into Manhattan's most compelling cocktail destination, where James Beard nominee Matthew Piacentini's "high-end, low-key" philosophy creates an intimate yet social drinking experience unlike any other.

The Up & Up occupies a subterranean sanctuary with remarkable heritage—once an underground gay club in the 1930s, a Beat Generation gathering place in the 1950s, and a Folk Music Revival hub in the 1960s. Piacentini, acclaimed for his work at Portland's Clyde Common (named "Best Hotel Bar in the World" at Tales of the Cocktail), partnered with head bartender Chaim Dauermann to honor this cultural legacy while establishing new standards for New York City cocktail bars. Their vision centers on honest hospitality and quality craftsmanship, reflected in the bar's name—a nod to the late 1800s phrase meaning legitimate and respectable.

The cocktail program showcases Piacentini and Dauermann's innovative approach to luxury bars New York City. Signature creations include the Foster Avenue, featuring Glenmorangie Scotch, Perucchi Vermouth, Pear Eau de Vie, honeydew melon, and orange bitters, alongside the house specialty Red House Cobbler—gin, Fino sherry, lime juice, and raspberries inspired by William Morris's Arts & Crafts movement. The menu extends beyond traditional offerings with bottled cocktails from bartenders nationwide, inventive "Halfies" (miniature cocktails for sampling), and an exceptional sherry selection available upon request. This premium craft cocktail approach balances complexity with approachability, ensuring every guest discovers their perfect drink.

The design brilliantly merges Vienna circa 1902 elegance with 1970s basement nostalgia, creating an atmosphere both intimate and spacious—a rarity among best cocktail bars in New York City. The standout Blackthorn wallpaper by Morris & Co. (1892) reflects the bar's kinship with Arts & Crafts ideals, while thoughtful finishes and minimal decor enhance the sophisticated ambiance. Unlike cramped Manhattan cocktail lounges, The Up & Up offers genuine comfort with plush seating and warm lighting that invites lingering conversations.

The service philosophy emphasizes warm hospitality without pretension, with talented staff ensuring every guest feels welcomed regardless of crowd size. The bar maintains a relaxed, unhurried pace that allows proper appreciation of both the mixology artistry and the space's remarkable atmosphere. Smart casual dress is appropriate, though the elevated setting naturally encourages refined attire.

For discerning travelers seeking authentic New York City luxury bar experiences, The Up & Up reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekend evenings. This subterranean gem perfectly captures Greenwich Village's bohemian spirit while delivering world-class cocktails in a setting where nearly a century of cultural history enhances every sip.