Chateau Montelena launches its first sparkling wine and debut brandy to mark 50 years since the 1976 Judgment of Paris — both rooted in the original 1973 vineyards.
That result did not simply flatter one Calistoga winery. It opened the door for every serious American producer that followed, in Napa, Sonoma, the Santa Cruz Mountains, and beyond. The Judgment of Paris, now at its 50th anniversary, is not nostalgia for a single tasting. It marks the moment California wine earned the right to be taken seriously on its own terms, without apology or qualification. For Chateau Montelena to choose this milestone as the occasion to debut two entirely new categories, sparkling wine and brandy, says something deliberate about how the estate views its own trajectory.
The Barrett family has owned Chateau Montelena for over fifty years, and CEO Bo Barrett has stewarded the winery through decades of vintage variation, shifting critical tastes, and the ongoing pressure that comes with being the estate that won Paris. The decision to mark the Chateau Montelena Judgment of Paris anniversary not with a retrospective bottling of the 1973 but with two forward-facing debut releases reflects a confidence that the legacy is best honored by continuing to move.
The two releases share a single conceptual thread: both draw their Chardonnay from the vineyards that comprised the original 1973 blend. This is not a marketing connection, it is a literal one. The fruit that went into the wine that changed the conversation in Paris in 1976 came from three specific Napa Valley sites: John Muir Hanna, Belle Terre, and Bacigalupi. Those three vineyards are the source material for both the 2023 Blanc de Blanc and Brandy Release #01.
Matthew Crafton, President and Winemaker of Chateau Montelena, was direct about the intent: "The Blanc de Blancs and the brandy both trace back to the same ground that produced the 1973 Chardonnay. They aren't re-creations of that wine, nothing could be, but they are honest expressions of the same vineyards, approached with the curiosity and discipline that have always defined Montelena."
That framing matters. Crafton is not claiming equivalence with the 1973, he is claiming continuity of place and approach. For collectors, that distinction is the point. These are not anniversary keepsakes. They are debut productions from a winery with a half-century of institutional knowledge about three specific Napa parcels, released at a moment when the cultural context for those parcels has never been higher.
The 2023 Blanc de Blanc is sourced entirely from the John Muir Hanna Vineyard, one of the three original sites behind the 1973 Chardonnay, and a parcel that has supplied fruit exclusively to Montelena since 1972 through a longstanding family partnership that continues today. That is an unbroken fifty-four-year exclusive relationship between a single vineyard and a single producer, which is rare even by Napa Valley standards.
This is Chateau Montelena's first sparkling wine. The winery has built its reputation on still Chardonnay and Cabernet Sauvignon, and the decision to debut a Blanc de Blanc, rather than a Blanc de Noirs or a non-vintage blend, keeps the focus squarely on the grape variety and the vineyard site that define the estate's identity. The 2023 vintage is produced in limited quantities. Pricing is $125 for members and $150 for non-members.
For those tracking Napa sparkling wine as a category, this release carries specific weight. The region has not historically been associated with sparkling production the way the Anderson Valley or the Santa Lucia Highlands have, but the raw material argument for Napa Chardonnay in a sparkling context is not a new one, it has simply been underexplored by the valley's most established estates. Montelena entering the category with a vineyard-designated Blanc de Blanc from a site with this particular provenance is a meaningful first data point.
The winery describes the Blanc de Blanc as built to evolve over time, which, given Montelena's track record with age-worthy still wines, suggests this is not a release designed for immediate consumption. Collectors who have followed the estate's Chardonnay program will recognize the philosophy: patience is part of the proposition.
Brandy Release #01 is Chateau Montelena's debut spirit, and its sourcing is the most direct possible link to the Judgment of Paris: Chardonnay distilled from all three original vineyards, John Muir Hanna, Belle Terre, and Bacigalupi, the complete triptych that produced the 1973 wine. Where the Blanc de Blanc draws on one of those sites, the brandy assembles all three.
This is the first in a planned series of ten sequential bottlings. According to the winery, each release in the series will carry a distinct profile shaped by carefully selected cooperage and extended aging, meaning the ten bottlings are not simply annual reissues of the same liquid, but a structured exploration of how cooperage and time interact with this specific distillate. That is a collector's proposition with a ten-release arc: buy in at #01, and you have the beginning of a series whose full shape will only become clear over time.
Production is extremely limited. Every bottle of Brandy Release #01 is hand-filled, hand-labeled, individually numbered, and signed. There is no industrial shortcut in that finishing process, each bottle is a discrete object. Pricing is $75 for members and $95 for non-members, which positions this as an accessible entry point into what could become a significant collector series if the subsequent releases deliver on the cooperage and aging program the winery has outlined.
Napa Valley brandy is not a crowded category. The valley's identity is so thoroughly defined by Cabernet Sauvignon and, to a lesser extent, Chardonnay, that distilled spirits from estate fruit remain genuinely rare. For Montelena to launch a brandy program rooted in the three vineyards that produced the most historically significant California Chardonnay ever made is a provenance argument that no other producer in the state can replicate. The fruit is exclusive. The history is singular. The series has nine more chapters to write.
Both the 2023 Blanc de Blanc and Brandy Release #01 are primarily allocated to Chateau Montelena members. The winery is making a small public allocation of each available over Independence Day weekend, July 3 through July 5, until supplies last. That three-day window is the only confirmed public access point for non-members at launch.
For context on what "small allocation" means in practice: Montelena's most sought-after releases have historically moved quickly through member channels, and debut productions from historically significant estates tend to attract collector attention that outpaces supply. The July 3 to 5 window is not a soft deadline, it is a hard close tied to available inventory, which for a hand-filled, individually numbered debut spirit and an inaugural sparkling wine from a limited harvest, could be measured in days rather than weeks.
Members receive preferential pricing, $125 versus $150 for the Blanc de Blanc, and $75 versus $95 for the brandy, and, more practically, first access before the public window opens. If either release is on your radar, the member channel is the lower-friction path.
Chateau Montelena is located in Calistoga, at the northern end of Napa Valley, a town whose volcanic soils and slightly cooler growing conditions have long set its wines apart from the warmer valley floor further south. The estate sits at the base of Mount Saint Helena, and the winery's stone château remains one of the most architecturally distinctive in the region. A visit to Calistoga pairs naturally with the broader northern Napa experience: the town has its own appellation identity, a concentration of serious producers, and a pace that rewards spending more than a single afternoon.
For collectors who track anniversary and debut releases from historically significant estates, the secondary market context is worth considering.
First editions from wineries with documented provenance, particularly those tied to a specific, datable cultural event like the Judgment of Paris, have a track record of attracting sustained collector interest once the initial allocation closes.
Brandy Release #01, as the first in a ten-part series from a winery whose three source vineyards cannot be replicated elsewhere, sits at the intersection of scarcity and narrative. The nine releases that follow will either validate or complicate the story that #01 begins, but the first bottling in any series is the one you cannot go back and acquire later.
The 50th anniversary of the Judgment of Paris lands in 2026 as a genuine inflection point for American wine history, and Chateau Montelena has chosen to mark it not by looking back at 1973, but by putting new liquid in bottle from the same ground. Whether the 2023 Blanc de Blanc and Brandy Release #01 become benchmarks in their own right will take time to determine. What is already clear is that the winery has committed its most historically resonant fruit to two entirely new formats, with a ten-release brandy arc still ahead of it.
Get the App
Take the shortlist into the En Primeur Club app for concierge access, saved places, and the next step after discovery.
Get Exclusive AccessMore from the editors
