top of page
< Back

Barely Disfigured

Cocktail speakeasy

257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

OUR SCORE

average rating is 4 out of 5

4

ACCOLADES

N/A

REVIEW & BAR SUMMARY

Behind an unassuming facade in Brooklyn's Cobble Hill, Barely Disfigured New York City transforms the art of cocktail culture into an immersive surrealist experience. Named after a Paul Éluard poem, this captivating establishment weaves French salon elegance with speakeasy mystique, creating an atmosphere that feels like stepping into an avant-garde theater production.

The bar's compelling origin story begins with its location—a former house of ill-repute whose colorful history is subtly woven throughout the space. Owner Andre has masterfully transformed this provocative past into sophisticated design elements, from headboards repurposed as banquette backs to mirrored chambers that blur reality and reflection. This thoughtful integration of history with artistry has established Barely Disfigured as Brooklyn's most intriguing cocktail destination, earning recognition among New York City's discerning drinking elite.

The ambitious cocktail program at Barely Disfigured elevates mixology to theatrical heights. Signature creations like the "Velvet Revolver"—a sophisticated blend of aged bourbon, vermouth, and bittersweet chocolate—exemplify the bar's commitment to both innovation and refinement. The "Siren's Call" offers a lighter counterpoint with crisp gin, cucumber essence, and elderflower liqueur, while the "Scarlet Mirage" delivers complexity through tequila, pomegranate syrup, and fresh lime with a spicy finish. Each cocktail represents a carefully orchestrated balance of premium spirits and unexpected ingredients, positioning the bar firmly in the luxury cocktail tier while maintaining artistic integrity.

The physical experience centers around a stunning 22-person curving marble bar that serves as both functional workspace and sculptural centerpiece. The intimate interior flows seamlessly into an expansive 1,800-square-foot garden accommodating over 100 guests, creating versatility rare among New York City cocktail bars. Dimly lit corners, velvet drapes, and strategic lighting design foster an atmosphere of secretive sophistication reminiscent of immersive theater experiences.

Service at Barely Disfigured reflects the bar's salon-inspired philosophy, with knowledgeable staff delivering attentive hospitality that enhances the sense of exclusivity. The bar operates late into the evening, extending to 1:30 AM on weekends, catering to both early evening sophisticates and late-night adventurers. Smart casual dress aligns with the elevated yet approachable atmosphere.

For luxury travelers seeking Brooklyn's most distinctive cocktail experience, Barely Disfigured offers an unparalleled blend of artistry, history, and mixological excellence. Reservations are recommended for this intimate space, particularly for garden seating during warmer months. The bar also accommodates private events, making it an ideal venue for exclusive gatherings that demand both sophistication and memorable ambiance.

Barely Disfigured

257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

NEARBY BARS

bottom of page