The Old '76 House
Our verdict
Book The Old '76 House for a historic American tavern meal where the room matters as much as the food. It is strongest for Sunday brunch, family gatherings, date nights, and celebrations, with classic comfort dishes, fireplaces, live music, garden and porch seating, and a restored landmark setting in Tappan’s Historic District.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.

The menu
What to order
- Shepherd's Pie
- Signature Pork Chop
- Vegan Moussaka
- Famous Yankee Pot Roast
- Onion Soup Lafayette
Book The Old '76 House for a historic American tavern meal where the room matters as much as the food. It is strongest for Sunday brunch, family gatherings, date nights, and celebrations, with classic comfort dishes, fireplaces, live music, garden and porch seating, and a restored landmark setting in Tappan’s Historic District.
Frequently asked questions
How far ahead should I plan for The Old '76 House?
If timing matters, contact The Old '76 House directly before planning a visit in Tappan.
Does The Old '76 House handle dietary restrictions?
The menu information includes Vegan Moussaka among the signature dishes, but it does not confirm broader allergy accommodations, gluten-free options, or other dietary policies.
Can The Old '76 House accommodate groups?
If you are planning for a group, confirm availability and setup directly with The Old '76 House.
Is The Old '76 House worth the price?
It can be, if you want American tavern cooking in Tappan at about $35 per person. The clearest draws are the cuisine type, casual dress code, and signature dishes such as Shepherd's Pie, Famous Yankee Pot Roast, Onion Soup Lafayette, the signature Pork Chop, and Vegan Moussaka.
Is The Old '76 House good for a special occasion?
It may still suit diners who want a casual American tavern meal in Tappan, but occasion-specific details should be confirmed directly.
What are alternatives to The Old '76 House in Tappan?
If you want a different style of meal, compare it with other dining in Tappan. Choose The Old '76 House when American tavern cooking, a casual dress code, and the listed signature dishes are the main appeal.
Is the tasting menu worth it at The Old '76 House?
The confirmed information centers on American tavern cuisine, a $35 per person price point, and signature dishes including Shepherd's Pie, signature Pork Chop, Vegan Moussaka, Famous Yankee Pot Roast, and Onion Soup Lafayette.
Continue exploring
More in Tappan
Restaurants in Tappan
All restaurants in Tappan →Bars in Tappan
Browse all →The Old '76 House
The wine
- Wine program
- Curated wine list
- Extensive wine list
- Beer program
Details
- Historic
- Cozy
- Romantic
- Classic
- Well Known
- Date Night
- Group Dining
- Solo
- Family
- Celebration
- Special Occasion
- Brunch
- Private Event
- Historic Building
- Live Music
- Garden
- Terrace
- Private Dining
- Standalone
- Beer Program
- Extensive Wine List
- Local Sourcing
- Farm To Table
- Garden
- A La Carte
- Buffet
- Beer
- Wine
- Vegetarian Friendly
- Vegan Options
- Gluten Free Options
Historic, cozy, and warm, with fireplaces, live music, a garden patio, and romantic porch seating in a restored landmark setting.



















