Behind the glowing red and green neon signage on Atlantic Avenue, The Long Island Bar New York City preserves six decades of Brooklyn history while serving some of the city's most expertly crafted cocktails. This corner institution transforms the neighborhood bar experience through Toby Cecchini's masterful mixology and lovingly restored mid-century design.

Originally opened in the late 1940s by Spanish immigrant Ramon Montero, The Long Island Bar served Brooklyn's longshoremen and locals for over fifty years under the stewardship of the Montero-Sullivan family. When renowned bartender Toby Cecchini—credited with popularizing the Cosmopolitan—and partner Joel Tompkins acquired the space in 2013, they embarked on a meticulous restoration that honored every vintage detail. Their reverence for the bar's heritage earned recognition from TimeOut NY and cemented its status among New York City's most authentic cocktail destinations.

The cocktail program at The Long Island Bar reflects Cecchini's decades of mixology expertise, emphasizing precision and balance in every pour. Classic cocktails like the Martini, Negroni, and Old Fashioned receive meticulous attention, crafted with premium spirits and house-made ingredients that elevate familiar favorites. Seasonal rotating cocktails showcase innovative techniques while respecting traditional foundations, creating a menu that satisfies both cocktail connoisseurs and neighborhood regulars. The carefully curated spirits selection and thoughtful wine list complement the cocktail offerings, positioning the bar firmly in New York City's luxury cocktail scene without sacrificing approachability.

Stepping inside reveals the bar's crown jewel: an immaculately preserved Art Deco interior featuring the original mahogany bar, terrazzo floors, and vintage glass shelving. Classic diner booths and period bar stools create intimate spaces for conversation, while atmospheric lighting casts a warm glow over the timeless design. Executive Chef Kevin Garrett's elevated bar menu—featuring standouts like deviled eggs and elevated burgers—transforms the space into a full dining destination. The service strikes a perfect balance between professionalism and neighborhood warmth, with knowledgeable staff who understand both cocktail history and guest comfort.

Reservations aren't required at The Long Island Bar, but arriving early ensures the best seating at this beloved Brooklyn institution. The bar welcomes both casual dress and elevated attire, embodying the democratic spirit that has defined it for generations. For discerning travelers seeking authentic New York City cocktail culture, The Long Island Bar offers an irreplaceable glimpse into Brooklyn's soul, where every drink tells the story of a neighborhood's enduring character.