top of page

Quality Italian

Italian-American

57 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

OUR SCORE

NOT YET RATEDaverage rating is null out of 5

Accolades

- Wine Spectator’s Award of Excellence (Multiple years)
- OpenTable Diners' Choice Award
- Featured on Zagat's list of Best Italian Restaurants in NYC
- Mentioned in The Infatuation's guide to NYC steakhouses

Note: The accolades listed above are based on historical recognition and might have changed. Please check with the restaurant or relevant awarding organizations for the most current list of accolades.

Restaurant Summary

Quality Italian, located in the heart of New York City, is a modern interpretation of the classic Italian-American steakhouse. Found just a block away from Central Park on 57th Street, this upscale dining establishment exudes a vibrant ambiance, making it a prime destination for both locals and visitors looking to indulge in exquisite cuisine.

The interior of Quality Italian presents a sophisticated blend of Old-World charm and contemporary elegance. With its leather banquettes, warm wood accents, and vintage-inspired lighting, the atmosphere invites diners to settle in for a memorable meal. The walls are adorned with black and white photographs that pay homage to Italy's rich culinary history, while the open kitchen adds an interactive and energetic layer to the dining experience.

Quality Italian's menu, crafted with an innovative twist on traditional steakhouse fare, highlights premium meats and fresh seafood complemented by an extensive wine list that includes both Italian varietals and global selections. One of the signature dishes that has garnered widespread acclaim is their Chicken Parmesan, which is ingeniously presented as a pizza, offering a delightful blend of crispy chicken with molten cheeses and tangy marinara sauce.

Another standout is the Dry-Aged Porterhouse Agnolotti, a refined dish that features beautifully stuffed pasta with concentrated flavors of dry-aged beef, accompanied by a robust truffle sauce. For those seeking a truly indulgent affair, the Tomahawk Ribeye is a must-try. This impressive cut is artfully charred and served with a selection of house-made steak sauces that elevate the flavors to new heights.

Seafood lovers will revel in the Spicy Lobster Rigatoni Alla Vodka, a dish that perfectly marries succulent lobster pieces with al dente pasta in a creamy and spicy tomato sauce. Vegetable sides, such as the Charred Broccoli with Sicilian pesto, provide a refreshing contrast and showcase the kitchen's commitment to using seasonally fresh and high-quality ingredients.

To finish off the meal, the dessert menu at Quality Italian offers sweet creations like the Toasted Coconut Cake layered with rich mascarpone cream and finished with a tangy passion fruit glaze, ensuring that your dining experience ends on an unforgettable note.

Quality Italian's dedication to exceptional service amplifies the dining experience. Knowledgeable staff are on hand to guide guests through the menu and assist with wine pairings, ensuring that every meal is perfectly tailored to the diners' preferences. Whether it's for a special occasion, a business meeting, or simply a luxurious night out, Quality Italian promises an opulent culinary journey through its inventive dishes and refined atmosphere.

-

FEATURED GUIDES

Quality Italian

57 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

NEARBY RESTAURANTS

bottom of page