DILL

Dining at the Edge of the Boreal Calendar

Iceland's culinary position has always been shaped by an extreme clock. In June, the sun barely sets; in December, daylight lasts four hours. That cycle does more to define what ends up on a plate in Reykjavík than any chef's aesthetic preference. Fermentation, smoking, salt-curing, and root-cellar storage were not techniques borrowed from Scandinavian fashion — they were the only options available for most of Iceland's habitation. What the New Nordic movement did, from Copenhagen outward, was reframe that necessity as philosophy. DILL, operating from a narrow address on Laugavegur 59 in central Reykjavík, is where that reframing takes its most formally recognised form in Iceland.

The restaurant is Iceland's sole Michelin-starred venue, a position it has held across the 2024 and 2025 guides. That singular status is not just a bragging point — it tells you something structural about Iceland's dining scene. The country's geography and population (roughly 370,000 people, with Reykjavík holding about half) make the economics of fine dining difficult at scale. There is no cluster of starred addresses here as there is in Copenhagen or Helsinki. DILL operates in relative isolation at the leading of that tier, which means it prices and positions itself against Nordic peers rather than a local competitive set.

What the Seasons Actually Do to the Menu

The midnight sun and polar night are not atmospheric details at DILL , they are the operating conditions. Summer brings an abundance of wild herbs, moss, crowberries, sea purslane, and lamb that has grazed on open highland pasture for months without supplemental feed. The flavour of that lamb is noticeably different from grain-finished alternatives: leaner, more mineral, with a faint grassiness that carries through to the plate. By contrast, winter menus lean into what has been preserved, dried, or cold-stored: fish that has been wind-dried on wooden racks, root vegetables, and fermented dairy that would not have survived unprepared past the first November frost.

Kitchen team forages directly, and the evidence is visible in the room itself , dried plants collected by staff hang as décor, collapsing the distance between the source landscape and the dining space. That integration is consistent with how the broader New Nordic tradition has developed, where the provenance narrative is made physical rather than simply narrated on a menu card. Comparable approaches appear at Kadeau Bornholm in Åkirkeby and Ræst in Tórshavn, where island geographies force the same logic of working with what the season provides rather than importing around it.

Where DILL Sits in the Nordic Fine Dining Tier

New Nordic movement has produced a defined upper tier across the region: multi-starred destination restaurants drawing international travel, operating on allocation booking, and priced at the leading of their national markets. Geranium in Copenhagen and RE-NAA in Stavanger represent that bracket. DILL sits one tier below in formal terms , a single Michelin star rather than multiple , but occupies a disproportionately significant position because it holds Iceland's only star. The Opinionated About Dining ranking places it at number 466 in Europe for 2025 (it ranked 364 in 2024), and La Liste scores it at 77 points for 2026, down from 85 in 2025. Those shifts are worth watching: they suggest a critical conversation still in progress rather than a settled consensus.

Within Reykjavík, the comparison set for serious tasting-menu dining includes ÓX, which operates a Nordic modern format at the same €€€€ price tier, and Hosiló, also at €€€€ with a modern cuisine focus. For traditional Icelandic cooking without the tasting-menu format, Matur og Drykkur operates at the same price point and draws on older recipe archives for its menu logic. At the less formal end, 3 Frakkar has run a seafood-focused kitchen for decades and represents a different entry point into Icelandic ingredients. Brút rounds out the modern cuisine options in the city for those building a multi-night dining itinerary.

Beyond Reykjavík, Moss in Grindavík represents Iceland's other serious fine dining address, positioned against a geothermal landscape. The two restaurants are not in direct competition , they draw different visitor profiles , but together they define what high-end dining looks like across the country. Those interested in the wider Nordic creative cooking tradition will find parallel grammar at VYN in Simrishamn and Grön in Helsinki.

Chef Gunnar Karl Gíslasson and the Icelandic Credential

Chef Gunnar Karl Gíslasson is the name most consistently attached to the development of contemporary Icelandic fine dining as a recognised category. His identification with Icelandic produce and landscape is documented across the awards record: the Michelin citation specifically notes seasonal working methods, local ingredients, and a connection to Icelandic nature strong enough to shape the vegetable-heavy direction of the cooking. That vegetable prominence is worth flagging practically: DILL can accommodate creative vegetarian menus, but guests should communicate this in advance, as no standard menu is available on a walk-in or default basis.

The kitchen's approach places it in the lineage of Scandinavian chefs who have used Nordic identity not as marketing but as a genuine constraint , working only what the landscape provides in that season, which means the menu changes materially from visit to visit. That variability is part of the value proposition at this tier, and it is also why a second or third visit often reads as a different restaurant.

Planning a Visit

DILL operates a restricted weekly schedule that rewards advance planning. Thursday through Saturday carry both lunch (12–3 pm) and dinner (6–9:30 pm) services; Thursday adds the dinner slot only, and Monday and Tuesday the restaurant is closed entirely. The dinner format at this price tier and with this awards profile warrants booking several weeks ahead, particularly for Friday and Saturday evenings when both services run and demand from international visitors is highest. The address at Laugavegur 59 places the restaurant on Reykjavík's main commercial street, walking distance from most central accommodation. Google reviews sit at 4.5 across 590 ratings, which at this price category indicates a consistent guest experience rather than polarised responses.

Guests with dietary requirements beyond standard exclusions , vegetarian menus in particular , should note that communication before arrival is necessary, as the absence of a fixed standard menu means accommodations need to be built into the kitchen's preparation rather than substituted on the night. Those building a broader Reykjavík itinerary can consult our full Reykjavík restaurants guide, alongside the hotels guide, bars guide, wineries guide, and experiences guide for the city.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the must-try dish at DILL?

DILL does not operate a fixed menu, so no single dish is available on every visit. The kitchen builds each service around what seasonal Icelandic ingredients are at their peak, which means the menu changes across the year and sometimes between services. Specific dish recommendations from verified visits consistently point to lamb and root vegetable preparations in autumn and winter, and wild herb and coastal ingredient combinations in summer , but the specific execution varies. What the awards record (Michelin star held in both 2024 and 2025, La Liste recognition) confirms is that the kitchen applies that seasonal logic with sufficient consistency to meet international fine dining standards. Guests who arrive without a fixed expectation of a specific dish and instead approach it as a seasonal document of Iceland's ingredient calendar tend to get the most from the format. Vegetarians should communicate their requirements when booking, as no standard alternative menu exists , the kitchen will build something specific, but needs to know in advance.