Seasonal American Seafood Restaurant
← Collection
Islip, United States
Bayberry
Price≈$50
ServiceUpscale Casual
NoiseConversational
CapacityMedium
Wine Spectator 2026 Award of Excellence winner. Cuisine: American. Wine strengths: California, France.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.
Plan your visit on PearlPlan Your Visit
Saves & bookings on Pearl
- Address
- 501 Main St.
- Phone
- (631) 210-0011
- Website
- bayberryislip.com
Saves & bookings on PearlAbout
Wine Spectator 2026 Award of Excellence winner. Cuisine: American. Wine strengths: California, France.
Signature Dishes
- 1890 Burger
- Lobster Roll
- Grilled Montauk Swordfish
- Pan Roasted Icelandic Cod
- Faroe Island Salmon
- Poke Tuna Bowl
Continue exploring
More in Islip
Restaurants in Islip
Browse all →
Bars in Islip
Browse all →
Hotels in Islip
Browse all →
At a Glance
Vibe
- Lively
- Cozy
- Elegant
- Trendy
- Intimate
Best For
- Date Night
- Group Dining
- Family
- Celebration
- Casual Hangout
- Special Occasion
- After Work
- Private Event
Experience
- Private Dining
- Standalone
Drink Program
- Craft Cocktails
Sourcing
- Local Sourcing
- Sustainable Seafood
Noise LevelConversational
CapacityMedium
Service StyleUpscale Casual
Meal PacingStandard
Elevated but relaxed American bistro atmosphere with polished decor, vibrant seafood-forward plates, and attentive, professional service, highlighted in wedding and guest reviews as warm and well-orchestrated.[3][10][11][13][14]
Signature Dishes
- 1890 Burger
- Lobster Roll
- Grilled Montauk Swordfish
- Pan Roasted Icelandic Cod
- Faroe Island Salmon
- Poke Tuna Bowl