Peter Luger Steak House
American
Peter Luger Steak House, Broadway, Brooklyn, NY, USA
OUR SCORE
Accolades
- Michelin Star (one star) consistently since 2006
- Zagat Survey rated #1 Steakhouse in New York for 24 years
- James Beard Foundation: America's Classics award winner in 2002
- "Best Steakhouse in New York City" by New York Magazine on multiple occasions
- Wine Spectator Magazine Award of Excellence
- Featured in The New York Times with a two-star review from Pete Wells in 2019 (Please note that critical perspectives can vary over time; this was a notable downgrade)
- Listed in Eater’s 38 Essential New York Restaurants multiple times
- Recognized in the book "1,000 Places to See Before You Die" by Patricia Schultz
Restaurant Summary
In the heart of Brooklyn, Peter Luger Steak House stands as a beacon of culinary mastery, exuding the timeless allure and classic ambiance characteristic of New York City's fine dining scene. Established in 1887, this Michelin-starred institution has long been revered by epicureans seeking the pinnacle of steakhouse experiences.
Upon crossing the threshold of Peter Luger's welcoming facade, guests are immediately enveloped in an atmosphere rich with history. The well-preserved décor, featuring svelte wooden furnishings and vintage brass chandeliers, echoes a bygone era of elite gastronomy, making diners part of a tradition that has spanned well over a century.
The menu at Peter Luger is a testament to the adage "if it's not broken, don't fix it," specializing in straightforward, uncompromisingly high-quality fare. The star of the show is indisputably the USDA Prime dry-aged steak, prepared with a time-honored technique that enhances its robust flavors and tender texture. The Porterhouse cut, revered by regulars and newcomers alike, is often ordered for two, three, or four diners, showcasing the restaurant's communal dining philosophy.
Accompanying the majestic steaks are classic side dishes that further define the Peter Luger experience. The creamed spinach, with its rich, velvety embrace, and the German potatoes, crispy on the outside and buttery soft on the inside, act as perfect foils to the meat's succulence. The sliced tomato and onion salad, anointed with the famous Peter Luger’s Old-Fashioned Sauce, provides a refreshing counterpoint to the hearty main courses.
No meal at Peter Luger would be complete without sampling the house-cured bacon, a thick-cut marvel served by the slice and beloved for its smoky depth and satisfying bite. While steak unquestionably reigns supreme, the establishment also caters to pescatarians with offerings like the broiled salmon or the daily fresh fish selections.
For those with a sweet tooth, the dessert menu does not disappoint. The signature schlag, or whipped cream, accompanies favorites such as the key lime pie and the "Holy Cow" hot fudge sundae, rounding out the dining experience with a touch of sweet indulgence.
In harmony with the exceptional food, Peter Luger’s service is renowned for its professionalism and old-world charm. Knowledgeable waitstaff, some of whom have been part of the restaurant's family for decades, navigate the bustling space with an air of confidence and familiarity that only adds to the venue's iconic status.
Peter Luger Steak House, with its uncompromising quality and historic ambiance, isn't simply a meal; it's a New York City institution, a rite of passage for carnivores, and a continuing chapter in the story of America's gastronomic excellence.
-