top of page

NY Pizza Suprema

Italian

413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001

OUR SCORE

NOT YET RATEDaverage rating is null out of 5

Accolades

- Voted one of the best pizza places in New York by Serious Eats
- Featured in the book "Pizza City: The Ultimate Guide to New York's Favorite Food"
- Rated as a top pizza destination in NYC on TripAdvisor
- Included in Eater NY’s list of 38 Essential New York City Pizzas
- Received a Certificate of Excellence from TripAdvisor
- Highlighted in the New York Times for its classic New York-style pizza
- Praised by Yelp users with high ratings and reviews for authentic New York pizza experience
- Mentioned in Thrillist’s roundup of the “Best Pizza in New York City”
- Recognized by Food Network as a must-visit pizza joint in New York City

Restaurant Summary

NY Pizza Suprema stands as a testament to the timeless allure of classic New York-style pizza. Since its inception in 1964, this family-run gem has been serving up a slice of the city’s history, becoming a pilgrimage site for pizza aficionados from around the globe. Its vintage charm and unpretentious ambiance invite guests to experience an authentic slice of the Big Apple, steeped in tradition and rich in flavor.

As you step into NY Pizza Suprema, the aromatic symphony of melting cheese, fresh tomato sauce, and oven-kissed dough greets you, promising satisfaction in every bite. The pizzeria's walls, adorned with nostalgic memorabilia, whisper tales of the city's yesteryears and the establishment’s culinary journey through decades.

The menu at NY Pizza Suprema is a showcase of mastery over the craft of pizza-making. The signature dish, the Suprema Special, is a masterful blend of savory Italian sausage, crisp pepperoni, a medley of bell peppers, and a generous helping of onions and mushrooms, all unified under a blanket of mozzarella that sings with every mouthful. For the traditionalist, the classic cheese pizza is anything but ordinary, with its perfect balance of rich, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese atop a thin, crispy crust.

But the culinary adventure doesn't end there. The White Pizza, a creamy, cheese-lover's dream, marries ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan in a delicate dance of flavors, offering a delightful departure from the tomato-based classics. Vegetarian visitors revel in the Veggie Pizza, a colorful array of fresh, seasonal vegetables that celebrate the pizzeria's commitment to freshness and quality.

As if straight from the streets of Naples, the Margherita Pizza is simplicity perfected, with sweet San Marzano tomato sauce, aromatic basil, and fresh mozzarella cheese transported into an art form. And for those seeking a meaty indulgence, the Meat Supreme Pizza with its hearty toppings of sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, and bacon is an irresistible, carnivorous delight.

At NY Pizza Suprema, every slice is more than just a meal—it's a slice of New York’s cultural tapestry, a beloved ritual for city dwellers, and an unforgettable experience for visitors. It's where the love for the perfect pie is not just served; it's celebrated with every pizza crafted to perfection. Whether you’re seeking the comfort of a classic or the thrill of something new, your quest for the ultimate New York City pizza experience ends here.

-

FEATURED GUIDES

NY Pizza Suprema

413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001

NEARBY RESTAURANTS

bottom of page