Butterfly Café
Butterfly Café serves American seafood at 2600 Overseas Hwy, with a waterfront setting and an extensive wine list for dinner plans.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.
- Address
- 2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
- Phone
- +13052897177
- Website
- tranquilitybay.com
Saves & bookings on Pearl
Panko Encrusted Florida Grouper
Panko Encrusted Florida Grouper, Florida Keys’ Shrimp Cocktail, and To Die For Sticky Toffee Pudding define the named dishes. American seafood and local sourcing keep the focus tied to the Keys.
Waterfront terrace at Tranquility Bay Resort
Waterfront terrace seating sits within Tranquility Bay Resort at 2600 Overseas Hwy. Conversation-level noise and leisurely pacing make it fit a longer dinner without requiring formal dress.
Extensive wine list
Tranquility Bay Resort frames the upscale casual service, and Butterfly Café pours from an extensive wine list. Casual dress applies for dinner centered on American seafood.
A Quick Peer Check
Comparable venues nearby, for context on price, style, and recognition.
| Venue | Cuisine | Price | Awards | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butterfly Café | American Seafood | $$$ | , | Marathon |
| Cracked Conch Cafe | Fresh Seafood & Conch Specialties | $$ | , | Marathon |
| Sadelle's Coconut Grove | New York-Style Deli | $$$ | , | Coconut Grove |
| Pinch Kitchen | New American Small Plates | $$$ | , | Shorecrest |
| The House on the River | American Seafood with Mediterranean Influences | $$$ | , | Sailboat Bend |
| Watermark Grille | American Steakhouse & Seafood | $$$ | , | North Naples |
Continue exploring
More in Marathon
Restaurants in Marathon
Browse all →
At a Glance
- Scenic
- Cozy
- Sophisticated
- Date Night
- Family
- Special Occasion
- Waterfront
- Terrace
- Extensive Wine List
- Local Sourcing
- Waterfront
Current opening hours
- Monday
- 6–9 PM
- Tuesday
- 6–9 PM
- Wednesday
- 6–9 PM
- Thursday
- 6–9 PM
- Friday
- 6–9 PM
- Saturday
- 6–9 PM
- Sunday
- 6–9 PM
Hours can change for holidays and private events. Last verified .
Airy dining room with soaring ceilings and casual sophisticated decor, or covered outdoor patio with waterfront views and relaxing island vibe.