A Slice of New York Squared
Our verdict
Walk in for the 72-hour sourdough Sicilian square pies, not for a formal night out. This small South Side counter spot is a strong $$ choice for lunch, after work, or a casual group pizza run, especially if the dough and fior di latte cheese matter more than table service.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.
- Address
- 319 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA
- Phone
- (412) 785-7198
- Website
- asliceofnewyorksquared.com
- Directions
- Get directions
The menu
What to order
- 12x12 Sicilian pies
- 72-hour fermented sourdough pizza
- Fior di latte Sicilian square pizza
For casual, specific-format dining beyond this Pittsburgh pizza stop, Pearl also covers other focused restaurants in different cities.
Frequently asked questions
What should I order at A Slice of New York Squared?
Start with the Sicilian square pies, especially the 72-hour fermented sourdough pizza or the Fior di latte Sicilian square pizza. That is the format this Pittsburgh spot is built around.
Does A Slice of New York Squared handle dietary restrictions?
Dietary or allergy-accommodation details are not available here. If you have a specific restriction, check the venue's official channels before visiting.
What should I wear to A Slice of New York Squared?
Keep it casual. A Slice of New York Squared has a compact, neighborhood-style feel in Pittsburgh, so relaxed clothes fit the setting better than dressed-up attire.
Is lunch or dinner better at A Slice of New York Squared?
A midday visit is possible on days when the venue is open from 11:00 am, while evening visits are only an option on the days with evening hours. It is closed Monday and Tuesday, open Wednesday from 11:00 am to 3:00 pm, Thursday from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, and Sunday from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm.
Is A Slice of New York Squared good for a special occasion?
Only for a low-key special occasion, not a formal one. The appeal is the compact, casual setup and Sicilian sourdough square pies at $$, which works for a relaxed pizza stop but not for a polished celebration.
Is A Slice of New York Squared worth the price?
Yes, if you want a focused Sicilian sourdough pizza stop rather than a formal dinner. At $$, the value comes from the 72-hour fermented sourdough pies and compact, pizza-first experience.
Continue exploring
More in Pittsburgh
Restaurants in Pittsburgh
Browse all →Bars in Pittsburgh
Browse all →Details
- Lively
- Cozy
- Trendy
- Industrial
- Casual Hangout
- Group Dining
- After Work
- Late Night
- Solo
- Standalone
- Zero Waste
- Street Scene
- A La Carte
- Allergy Accommodating
A compact sourdough-Sicilian pizza spot at The Highline with a casual, neighborhood feel focused on quality pies and beer-garden adjacent outdoor energy rather than formal dining.












