The Depot

Auburn's Dining Character and Where The Depot Fits

American college towns occupy an unusual position in the national dining conversation. They sustain enough resident foot traffic to support serious restaurants, yet their identity is frequently written by the university calendar rather than by culinary ambition. Auburn, Alabama is no exception, but a small tier of restaurants here has pushed past game-day convenience food toward something more considered. The Depot, at 124 Mitcham Ave, belongs to that tier: an American and seafood kitchen operating at the $$ price point, serving lunch and dinner, with a wine program that carries more depth than the room's casual register might suggest.

In the broader geography of the American South, seafood cookery has deep roots that run well past the Gulf Coast tourist trail. The inland translation of that tradition, through Alabama and into the college-town context of Auburn, tends to favor accessible preparations over high-concept plating. The Depot works within that framework rather than against it, positioning itself as the kind of place where the food is taken seriously without the self-consciousness that can flatten a dining room's energy. Compare that approach to the fine-dining register of 1856 Restaurant ($$$$ · Contemporary) on the other end of Auburn's spectrum, and The Depot reads clearly as the mid-market anchor: lower stakes, broader access, and a wine list that over-delivers for its price tier.

American and Seafood Cooking in a Southern Context

The cultural weight behind American seafood cooking in the South is worth taking seriously. Long before coastal fine-dining institutions like Le Bernardin in New York City or Providence in Los Angeles formalized seafood as a prestige category, Southern cooks were building flavor through simpler, more direct means: cast iron, smoke, acid, and the quality of the catch itself. That lineage matters when reading a restaurant like The Depot. At the $$ price point, a two-course meal running $40–$65 before beverages and tip, the kitchen is not competing with the tasting-menu ambitions of places like Lazy Bear in San Francisco or Alinea in Chicago. Instead, it draws from a different tradition: honest American cooking where the measure of success is execution and consistency rather than conceptual novelty.

Chef Scott Simpson, who also carries an ownership stake alongside Matt and Jana Poirier, leads the kitchen within that framework. The co-ownership structure is common in this tier of American dining outside major metros, it tends to produce kitchens where the chef is invested in repeat business rather than in burnishing a personal brand, which generally translates to more reliable day-to-day cooking. That dynamic is a useful marker when deciding where to eat in a college town, where turnover among kitchens can be high and the incentive structures for independent operators differ from those driving destination restaurants like The French Laundry in Napa or The Inn at Little Washington.

The Wine Program: Where The Depot Overperforms Its Category

The clearest signal that The Depot is operating with more intention than a typical mid-range American restaurant is its wine program. Ashton Puckett, who serves as both Wine Director and General Manager, oversees a list with 145 selections and a physical inventory of 790 bottles. That inventory depth is substantial for a $$ restaurant in a city of Auburn's size; many restaurants at this price tier in comparable markets carry a fraction of that stock and rely heavily on by-the-glass pours with limited cellar depth behind them.

The list's strengths sit in California and France, which places it in recognizable territory for American diners but does not imply it is generic. California and France together cover enough stylistic range, from lean coastal Chardonnay to structured Napa Cabernet and the full Burgundy and Rhône spectrum, that a list built on those two regions can reward both the wine-curious and the experienced drinker. Pricing falls in the $$ band, meaning the list spans a range rather than clustering entirely at the entry level or at the high end. A $25 corkage fee applies for guests bringing their own bottles, which is a direct policy and a reasonable one for a restaurant with a serious program of its own.

For context: at the higher end of the American wine-forward dining spectrum, programs at restaurants like Single Thread Farm in Healdsburg or Blue Hill at Stone Barns in Tarrytown operate at entirely different scales and price points. The Depot is not in that conversation. What it offers instead is proportionally strong wine coverage for its tier and market, which is the relevant comparison for a mid-range Auburn restaurant.

Planning a Visit

The Depot operates at 124 Mitcham Ave for both lunch and dinner service. The $$ cuisine pricing puts a two-course meal before drinks in the $40–$65 range, which positions it as the kind of place worth considering for a weeknight dinner or a post-game meal rather than a special-occasion splurge. For visitors arriving in Auburn and looking to orient themselves across the full dining, hotel, and nightlife spectrum, our full Auburn restaurants guide maps the competitive set clearly; the Auburn hotels guide, bars guide, wineries guide, and experiences guide cover the surrounding picture. Phone and reservations details were not available at time of writing; confirming service hours and booking availability directly before visiting is advisable, particularly around university event dates when Auburn's dining rooms fill quickly.