The Terrace Restaurant
Wine Spectator Award of Excellence
Our verdict
Wine Spectator 2026 Award of Excellence winner. Cuisine: Mediterranean / American. Wine strengths: France, California.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.
The menu
What to order
- Pridwin lobster roll
- Montauk striped bass
- Crab cake
- Shrimp and grits
Wine Spectator 2026 Award of Excellence winner. Cuisine: Mediterranean / American. Wine strengths: France, California.
Recognition history
Dated appearances from independent guides and award organizations, with the underlying list record or original source where available.
Wine Spectator Award of Excellence
Wine Spectator
Continue exploring
More in Shelter Island
Restaurants in Shelter Island
All restaurants in Shelter Island →
Bars in Shelter Island
Browse all →
The Terrace Restaurant
The wine
The Terrace Restaurant holds the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence, which Wine Spectator gives to lists of usually 90 or more selections.
- Wine program
- Curated wine list
- Wine Spectator
- Wine Spectator Award of Excellence
- Extensive wine list
- Craft cocktails
Details
- Scenic
- Romantic
- Classic
- Elegant
- Well Known
- Date Night
- Group Dining
- Family
- Celebration
- Special Occasion
- Casual Hangout
- Private Event
- Waterfront
- Terrace
- Panoramic View
- Historic Building
- Design Destination
- Hotel Restaurant
- Extensive Wine List
- Craft Cocktails
- Local Sourcing
- Farm To Table
- Sustainable Seafood
- Waterfront
- A La Carte
- Wine
- Cocktails
- Pescatarian Friendly
Upscale yet relaxed coastal atmosphere with warm, attentive service, combining hotel-guest polish with a casual beachside feel and golden-hour lighting over the bay.