The Easterly
Our verdict
The Easterly is worth booking when the brief is relaxed Red Hook dinner with better-than-basic seafood, cocktails, and a waterfront setting. Go for wood-fired fish, raw seafood preparations, and a lively upscale-casual atmosphere rather than a formal tasting-menu night.
Pearl is the En Primeur Club membership app — saves, bookings, and concierge access live there. Same editors, same standards.
The menu
What to order
- Ceviches
- Crudos
- Grilled octopus
- Shellfish and lobster
- Whole wood-fired grilled fish
The Easterly is worth booking when the brief is relaxed Red Hook dinner with better-than-basic seafood, cocktails, and a waterfront setting. Go for wood-fired fish, raw seafood preparations, and a lively upscale-casual atmosphere rather than a formal tasting-menu night.
Frequently asked questions
Is The Easterly worth the price?
It can be, if you want rustic Caribbean seafood and wood-fired cooking in St. Thomas and plan around a $75-per-person price. The value comes from dishes such as ceviches, crudos, grilled octopus, shellfish and lobster, and whole wood-fired grilled fish.
Can The Easterly accommodate groups?
If you are planning a group dinner, treat The Easterly as a smart-casual St. Thomas dinner option and confirm any party-size needs directly before going.
Is The Easterly good for solo dining?
A solo diner can consider it for dinner if the goal is rustic Caribbean seafood and wood-fired cooking at $75 per person.
What should I order at The Easterly?
Focus on the seafood and wood-fired side of the menu: ceviches, crudos, grilled octopus, shellfish and lobster, or whole wood-fired grilled fish. Those are the signature dishes and the clearest match for the restaurant’s rustic Caribbean seafood identity.
What are alternatives to The Easterly in St. Thomas?
Look for other dining in St. Thomas if you want a different price point, setting, or style. The Easterly is the option to consider when your priority is rustic Caribbean seafood and wood-fired cooking at $75 per person.
Is The Easterly good for a special occasion?
It may fit a special-occasion dinner if the occasion calls for smart-casual rustic Caribbean seafood and wood-fired dishes in St. Thomas.
How should I approach the menu at The Easterly?
Based on the supplied information, the safest plan is to order from the seafood and wood-fired signatures, including ceviches, crudos, grilled octopus, shellfish and lobster, and whole wood-fired grilled fish.
Continue exploring
More in St. Thomas
Restaurants in St. Thomas
All restaurants in St. Thomas →
Bars in St. Thomas
Browse all →
The Easterly
The wine
- Wine program
- Curated wine list
- Extensive wine list
- Craft cocktails
- Beer program
Details
- Scenic
- Rustic
- Bohemian
- Romantic
- Energetic
- Date Night
- Group Dining
- Celebration
- Special Occasion
- Casual Hangout
- After Work
- Waterfront
- Open Kitchen
- Design Destination
- Standalone
- Terrace
- Craft Cocktails
- Beer Program
- Extensive Wine List
- Local Sourcing
- Sustainable Seafood
- Waterfront
- Garden
- A La Carte
- Small Plates
- Cocktails
- Beer
- Wine
- Pescatarian Friendly
Current opening hours
- Monday
- 5–11 pm
- Tuesday
- 5–11 pm
- Wednesday
- 5–11 pm
- Thursday
- 5–11 pm
- Friday
- 5–11 pm
- Saturday
- 5–11 pm
- Sunday
- 5–11 pm
Hours can change for holidays and private events. Last verified .
A lush, breezy waterfront setting tucked among palm trees and rich greenery, with a bohemian island vibe and rustic Caribbean design, wood-fired kitchen aromas, and an upscale-casual yet laid‑back atmosphere that feels like a hidden dining oasis.